Skip to main content
replaced http://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/ with https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

My editMy edit to the question Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE!Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE! was rejected with the standard This edit deviates from the original intent of the post.

We have of course to guess at the intent of the post. I assume it is to get answers, and then the amount of non-essential text does not really help.

Aren't SE sites supposed to be about (concise) Questions and answers? All this excess verbiage does not help the OP getting answers IMO.
Does Worldbuilding allow more prose?

Note that the question has been edited later.

Similar cases:
Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?
How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?

My edit to the question Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE! was rejected with the standard This edit deviates from the original intent of the post.

We have of course to guess at the intent of the post. I assume it is to get answers, and then the amount of non-essential text does not really help.

Aren't SE sites supposed to be about (concise) Questions and answers? All this excess verbiage does not help the OP getting answers IMO.
Does Worldbuilding allow more prose?

Note that the question has been edited later.

Similar cases:
Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?
How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?

My edit to the question Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE! was rejected with the standard This edit deviates from the original intent of the post.

We have of course to guess at the intent of the post. I assume it is to get answers, and then the amount of non-essential text does not really help.

Aren't SE sites supposed to be about (concise) Questions and answers? All this excess verbiage does not help the OP getting answers IMO.
Does Worldbuilding allow more prose?

Note that the question has been edited later.

Similar cases:
Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?
How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?

replaced http://meta.stackexchange.com/ with https://meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

My edit to the question Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE! was rejected with the standard This edit deviates from the original intent of the post.

We have of course to guess at the intent of the post. I assume it is to get answers, and then the amount of non-essential text does not really help.

Aren't SE sites supposed to be about (concise) Questions and answers? All this excess verbiage does not help the OP getting answers IMO.
Does Worldbuilding allow more prose?

Note that the question has been edited later.

Similar cases:
Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?
How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?

My edit to the question Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE! was rejected with the standard This edit deviates from the original intent of the post.

We have of course to guess at the intent of the post. I assume it is to get answers, and then the amount of non-essential text does not really help.

Aren't SE sites supposed to be about (concise) Questions and answers? All this excess verbiage does not help the OP getting answers IMO.
Does Worldbuilding allow more prose?

Note that the question has been edited later.

Similar cases:
Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?
How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?

My edit to the question Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE! was rejected with the standard This edit deviates from the original intent of the post.

We have of course to guess at the intent of the post. I assume it is to get answers, and then the amount of non-essential text does not really help.

Aren't SE sites supposed to be about (concise) Questions and answers? All this excess verbiage does not help the OP getting answers IMO.
Does Worldbuilding allow more prose?

Note that the question has been edited later.

Similar cases:
Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?
How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?

Source Link
user3106
user3106

Is this rejected edit in line with SE goals?

My edit to the question Overpopulation . . . IN SPACE! was rejected with the standard This edit deviates from the original intent of the post.

We have of course to guess at the intent of the post. I assume it is to get answers, and then the amount of non-essential text does not really help.

Aren't SE sites supposed to be about (concise) Questions and answers? All this excess verbiage does not help the OP getting answers IMO.
Does Worldbuilding allow more prose?

Note that the question has been edited later.

Similar cases:
Why was this edit rejected for changing the original post too much?
How does this edit suggestion changes the original meaning or intent of the post?