This question – Is my map realistic? – was closed for being too vague and/or opinion-based. The asker was advised to clarify the nature of the question and provide necessary information. The asker also displayed (in comments and a deleted answer) a willingness to accept all sorts of feedback without any specific focus, effectively subverting the SE format and turning the question into an Infinite List of Things on any given aspect (geography, weather, environemnt, city placement, "etc") someone may glean from the map.
So why was it reopened without any edits from the question asker or explanation from mods? There are now four replies, one with over 20 upvotes, which would be invalidated if the asker were to actually narrow the focus or provide additional information as required by the site.