There is a type of question on this site, that asks something like "given these parameters, what would be the effect on society?" A recent example of this type of question was one Monty Wild asked. In that question Monty asked about what effects the presence of fairies would have one medieval, human society. Do we want this kind of "effect" question?
Just to be clear, I actually kinda like the question. I upvoted it, and answered it. But as I was answering it, I realized how broad it was. Monty asked the question well, there are very clear parameters about how the fairies look and how the interact with humans. But even then he can't include everything. Should these kind of questions be allowed? Should the answerer just assume things not mention in the question using logic?
Related meta questions: