5
$\begingroup$

Sometimes another user makes a lengthy edit to a question that leaves it substantially worse than it was to start with, contains grammatical errors, changes the intent, and is a huge pain to correct in detail.

Is there a way for the original author to revert that edit entirely?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Coincidentally I just asked a question on meta about the question to which you refer. See here $\endgroup$ – Zxyrra Dec 16 '16 at 5:23
8
$\begingroup$

Yes, it's called a rollback.

enter image description here

Go to the edit that you wish to change, and click the "rollback" button directly below the edit description. You should have sufficient reputation to do so (2000+).

If you are the owner of the post, you can always rollback it.

If the edit is for clarity and you do not like it, consider instead changing the edit itself or rolling back and making an edit of your own so that the idea of "clearing it up" is still preserved. If the editor had problems understanding, chances are they aren't the only one; even if you don't like their edit, you should find a way to make your question more clear.

$\endgroup$
3
$\begingroup$

As already discussed by Zxyrra, it is possible to reverse an edit entirely by performing a "rollback".

Important special case: SPAM! The one time when you absolutely should not roll back a post is if the edit turns the post into spam. In that case, do not touch the post at all but rather just flag it as spam and move on. It will be dealt with in short order, and if you edit it, your account could be tainted by the spam flag process as well. Don't risk that; it's simply not worth the benefit. For the same reason, you shouldn't edit spam posts either; just flag them and let the system do its thing. If you believe the owner of the post is legitimately not involved in spamming, but the post is still spam, flag it for moderator attention with a custom reason and point this out. If an edit somehow snuck through the review process and turned a legitimate post into spam, diamond moderators have the ability to reverse the spam flag penalty for the user, as long as we become aware of it; in such a case, a custom flag will ensure that the post is brought to the attention of the moderators, but you should also flag as spam with the system-defined flag reason. (Post owners: This is not the same thing as saying that the penalty will always be reversed. Any such posts will be dealt with on a case-by-case basis and ultimately at the discretion of the moderator handling the flag. Hopefully it will never be an issue.)

To roll back an edit, click the time indication in the "edited" block under the post in question:

First access the revision history by clicking the "edited" link

This brings up the revision history of the post. Find the revision of the post that you wish to roll back to, then click rollback above it:

Locate the revision you like and click "rollback" above it

You need to either be the owner of the post or have the Edit Questions and Answers privilege to roll back a post to a previous revision.

If you do not have the necessary privileges, and feel that the edit makes the post substantially worse, your choices are basically to:

  • Bring it up in the Worldbuilding Chat main chat room, The Factory Floor (this is probably the quickest; chat is usually pretty well populated), or
  • Bring it up on Meta (this is a good idea if it's more of a policy issue), or
  • Flag the post for moderator attention and (unless it is utterly obvious) describe how the edit makes the post substantially worse

Don't roll back unnecessarily if other alternative approaches are workable. Basically, only roll back a post to a previous revision if the new revision is decisively worse than the older one. If there is some particular part of the edit that you disagree with, it's better to edit further than to roll back. However, don't simply put back what was there before; instead of simply rolling back to the previous revision, whether by editing or by rollback, consider what the person who edited the post was trying to accomplish with their edit and try to maintain the spirit of the edit while making the post yet better.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Not an answer to this question, but relevant to the above answer: If you see a question that is spam, you should flag it as spam rather than voting to close (if you have the VTC privilege, granted at 3000 rep). $\endgroup$ – Peregrine Rook Dec 19 '16 at 20:51

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .