Recently, two of my questions were closed. It can be found here. The reason given for it being closed was,
This is a very broad questions. It would have a lot of implications on social, economic, and generally every aspects of the society. It is likely to produce a civil unrest or war. And your last questions focuses on situations where the whole step was done. So in the worst case, you ask us to describe hypothetically a few decades. That's what I call too broad. – bilbo_pingouin
However, this was after I edited it to make my focus how would the government deal with them. Which is precisely the advice given on the little ribbon that says it's closed (please add details to narrow the answer set or to isolate an issue). So why was it closed? Bilbo was the only one to even provide an answer as to why he voted to close, and I think he was going off of what he had read earlier. The other four people didn't even upvote his comment, much less provide a reason.
Is my question still too broad? Or is there some other reason my question is invalid?